Shootout: 3 Blu-ray Disc Players
So if you were to buy a BD player today, three of your options would be the $1300 Panasonic, the $1000 Samsung (though it can be had for much cheaper), and the $500 PS3. Sound & Vision magazine took a look at these three BD players, though I wonder why they didn’t include the Philips player, which is also currently available.
Maybe I should be writing this article over at PS3Blog.net. Why? Because the reviewer’s favourite BD player was the cheapest of them all - the PS3. Why?
This machine’s picture and sound quality were nothing short of stunning, and its HDMI 1.3 connection and built-in Dolby TrueHD decoding give it a layer of future-proofing that the other players currently lack. I also appreciated its multichannel Super Audio CD playback and 60-GB hard disk for storing compressed music files. And even though I don’t have much use for the PS3’s gaming capabilities, I definitely got a kick out of Resistance: Fall of Man. The PS3’s $600 price — several hundred less than the others — also goes a long way toward making it the Blu-ray Disc player of choice.
Yup, that’s what I have - a PS3! I use it as a BD player when I have a BD movie to watch (which is still not that often). But I can contest that it makes a really good BD player.
Also of note in the review is this:
A more interesting outcome was the mild “jaggies” that I noted when watching M:I III on HD DVD — a video artifact caused by the Sony projector’s deinterlacing of the Toshiba HD DVD player’s 1080i-format output. Not all TVs will have this problem, but it confirmed for me the advantage of using a true 1080p source like Blu-ray (Toshiba’s second-generation HD DVD player will feature 1080p output over HDMI, which should bring it up to speed with the players tested here).
Check out our new sister blog on Home Theater, HTBlog.net




