

Samsung has released theirBD player to the market, and for now it’s the sole standard-bearer for the BD format. Other players from Philips, Pioneer, Panasonic, and Sony are due to arrive in the fall. Mr. Norton from Ultimate AV took a look at Samsung’s offering, and gave it a good thrice-over.
As far as price goes, Mr. Norton does well to point out that Samsung’s not being unreasonable to ask $1000 for a new consumer electronics product. The first VCRs, DVD players, and CD players were more expensive, especially when you take inflation into account.
Something interesting that I haven’t seen reported elsewhere is the fact that the Samsung player will produce no output whatsoever on its component video outputs when a disc with ICT enabled is loaded into the player. This is contrary to the downconversion to 960 x 540 that is supposed to be standard.
Mr. Norton is quite thorough in the evaluation of this player’s features, so if you’re looking into buying this player, you have to read this review. I assume you’ll do that, so I’m just going to skip to the juicy stuff.
The juicy stuff being, of course, his thought on picture quality. And they go something like this. Picture quality on most movies he reviewed was okay - not as bad as many reports led him to believe, but not great either, often falling short of what HDTV is supposed to be. Then he hooked up a 1080p projector (versus the 720p one he’d been using) and the results improved across the board. But still nothing really spectacular. Well, except for Hitch on in 1080p. Which looked very good.
But the really juicy stuff came when he compared the Samsung player to a pre-release Pioneer player.
In every case, the Pioneer produced a more detailed image. The difference was not night and day, but it did make the difference between merely acceptable and superb high definition. While there were a few instances where I felt that the Pioneer might actually have been a little too sharp (it will take test patterns to determine if this was the case), overall it did not appear to be. Rather I was starting to see the same sort of resolution from Blu-ray on the Pioneer that I expect to see from a premium HD format, and which looked like it could, with top grade program material, equal what I’ve seen from HD DVD in image quality.
All in all, though, Mr. Norton was disappointed with with Blu-ray, which seems to the general consensus. Unfortunate for Sony and their fledgling Blu-ray format, things aren’t looking good for them right now.
Samsung BD-P1000 Blu-ray Disc Player