Over at HDTV Expert Peter Putman wrote a few articles on 1080p (1080p Reality Check, published in July 2005, and 1080p Q&A, published in August 2005).
Well Peter is back with some Q&A. Seems many people have been writing him about these articles and taking issue with many of his conclusions. Maybe with some prodding from me:

Or how about the fact that the typical consumer cannot distinguish between 1080i and 1080p unless a static image is displayed

Peter does a very good job of keeping calm and answering all the questions. He also had to remind people that the articles were written back in July of 2005, well before HD-DVD players were available and HDMI was just coming out.

The Masses Have Spoken