Blu-ray / HD-DVD Compromise?
MacWorld reports that there are rumblings from Sony that a compromise might be possible between the Blu-ray and HD-DVD camps. If this were to happen, the introduction of an HD optical disc format would have to be delayed further. It is unlikely that the Blu-ray consortium will just give up on Blu-ray and whole-heartedly embrace HD-DVD. It is equally unlikely that the HD-DVD camp would have a similar change of heart. So both parties would have to come to the table and hammer out a new standard that takes pieces from both. This would mean putting on hold the current plans to release Blu-ray and HD-DVD to market within the next year, thereby delaying the day consumers get to watch HD movies from an optical disc format.
So the theoretical choice comes to be between a unified format later, or two separate formats sooner. If, once the formats hit the market, one clearly becomes dominant in a short period of time, the answer is simpler than if there’s a long format war. But no matter what happens, the consumer loses: delay or two formats. No other choice.
Link: Macworld
Check out our new sister blog on Home Theater, HTBlog.net





March 27th, 2005 at 8:49 am
I think by a compromise they mean something like issuing all discs with HD-DVD on one side and Blu-ray on the other… not actually creating a new standard. It would be too time-consuming and expensive to abandon all their investment and development to date.
March 27th, 2005 at 12:23 pm
Good point. Though I don’t know what kind of benefit this would be to the HD-DVD group, considering the fact that the Blu-Ray side of the disc would be able to hold more and would therefore have more content.
Alternatively, HD-DVD could be the format for movies with little extras, and Blu-Ray be the format for movies with lots of extras. Even then, how would you market this?